Price freeze talk wont save oil bulls this fall

November 23, 2016 01:00 PM
Crude oil is well positioned for option sellers because it has remained in a relatively stable range while exhibiting sharp swings that keep premiums fat.

The Food Network runs a show called “Chopped” where chefs compete in producing various meals for judges. In a recent interview with one of these contestants, he explained how he creates a dish by starting with a few core ingredients and building it from there. 

This struck me as curiously similar to how a successful option seller should build his account.

When building an option selling portfolio for a client, we tend to start with a few core positions and add “garnishes” and “flavor” from there to properly balance the dish. 

Since the spring of 2016, selling crude oil calls has been one of these core positions. Good core positions based on solid fundamental reasoning don’t necessarily have to change often. Variety and new horizons are often pursued by the amateur who is trading for fun. But if you’re after the cash, you should think of yourself as a gold miner; once you hit a vein, you keep mining it until it runs dry. 

The same holds true in option selling. Selling crude oil calls has been a solid cash cow for most of the year for the portfolios I manage. The fundamentals of this market have not changed much during that time. Why go to another well if there is plenty of water left in this one?

Does this mean you should not diversify your short option holdings? Of course not. It means that you shouldn’t abandon a position simply because you get bored with it — as in “We’ve been selling these crude calls all year — let’s go sell some orange juice premium.”

This isn’t entertainment; this is cash mining, and a core principle of cash mining is that you don’t abandon profitable mines. You keep mining and mining for as long as the cash keeps coming. 
That’s why we recommended selling crude calls this spring, this summer and now this fall. Here’s a recap of current fundamentals and why selling calls in crude should continue to be a cash cow this fall.

bear fundamentals: 
going nowhere fast

Saying a market can’t rally is like saying it can’t rain. It can always rain anywhere in the world – although certain weather conditions can make it more or less likely  depending on location.

The same is true in crude oil. Prices can rally at any time. In August, they did. By late summer, funds had built a record net short position in the crude oil market. When this happens, the market becomes very vulnerable to short covering rallies. When the Saudis began talk of a production freeze last month, it was enough to trigger some of these funds to cover shorts. This drove the market marginally higher; although not enough to concern deep out-of-the-money option writers.

But the current fundamentals should continue to serve as a drag on any price rally and eventually pull prices back down. This is why you want to sell options in the first place. Short options are custom-made to absorb a certain amount of adverse movement while waiting for the fundamentals to do their thing. These kinds of fundamentals are what we feel will hinder bulls this fall. 

These include:

  1. Record U.S. supplies of crude; Oversupply is the proverbial Mammoth Gorilla in the room. No matter what the latest news story, it’s hard to ignore and it doesn’t appear to be going away anytime soon. As of the August  EIA report, crude supplies in the United States stood at 521 million barrels — an all-time record for this time of year and 37% higher than the five-year average for the same time of year and 14% higher than last year at this time (see “Surplus supply,” below).Entering September, crude oil supplies remain at record levels in the United States. News reports of outages and freeze talk are all fine and good, but at the end of the day it’s hard for a market to sustain a rally with this big of a monkey on the market’s back.
  2. The demand cycle has now shifted toward the bears. September marks the beginning of “shoulder season” in the United States — a time of year typically characterized by weak demand (see “Seasonal tendencies,” below). As driving season has now ended but heating season has not yet begun, demand can find itself in a rut. This has historically often served as a weight on crude prices.
  3. Don’t count on a production freeze.  The Saudis started talking about a production freeze a week after they announced record production of 10.67 million barrels per day in July.  So now they want to freeze production? At all-time record levels? Even if the Saudis do freeze production — a proposition that is highly questionable — freezing production at all-time highs won’t have much impact on overall supply. 

Ramp it up and then freeze? The Saudi talk of freezing production at record levels would likely do little to dent crude’s longer- term supply issues.

How to play it

With record supplies and bearish seasonal tendencies, we feel any rallies in the crude oil market will be of limited nature — at least into Q1 2017. And crude remains volatile, with numerous weekly swings of greater than 10%. This keeps premiums up. 

Traders should consider selling the March crude oil 70.00 calls. These options are offering premiums near $600 as of Sept. 6. Selling the March 70.00 crude call leaves a wide cushion for the market to rally while still positioning for bearish fundamentals.

If crude prices do indeed see a seasonal decline into December, profits on these options could potentially be reaped by years end. Remember, one of the top lessons in option selling is this: for short calls to profit, the market doesn’t necessarily have to decline. It only has to stay below your strike — in this case, $70 per barrel.

About the Author

James Cordier is the founder of, an investment firm specializing in writing commodities options for high net-worth investors. He is the author of The Complete Guide to Option Selling 3rd Edition (McGraw-Hill 2014).