Jump to navigation

Free Newsletter Modern Trader Follow

Main menu

  • Futures
    • Modern Trader Magazine
    • Commodities
    • Futures Mag Archives
    • ETFs
    • Financials
    • Forex
    • Managed Funds
    • Market Analysis
    • News
    • Options
    • Regulation
    • Technology
    • Trading Strategies
    • Education
    • Futures Op-Ed
  • Favorites
    • Alpha Pages Most Popular
    • Futures Magazine
    • Modern Trader Magazine
    • Most Popular
    • Slideshows & Lists
    • Special Topics
      • Alpha Hunters
      • Bad Boys
      • FINtech
      • High-Frequency Trading
      • Trader's Life
      • Trading Strategies
      • FUTURES MAG's 500th ISSUE
      • We asked traders
  • Traders
    • Market Data
    • Hot Charts
    • Interactive Charts
    • Trading Calendar
  • FINalternatives
  • Hard Assets
    • Home
    • Base Metals
    • Precious Metals
    • Rare Earth Metals
    • Commodities
    • Mining Investments
    • Slideshows
  • Modern Trader
    • Subscribe
    • Past Issues
  • All +
    • Follow Us +
      • FuturesMag
      • Newsletters
      • Facebook
      • Google+
      • Linkedin
      • Twitter
      • RSS Feeds
    • About Us +
      • About
      • Advertise
      • Contact
      • Contribute
      • Privacy Policy
  • !
Follow Futures          
       
more >>

We Asked Traders

We asked traders for their opinion on the launch of bitcoin futures

Sponsored Content

Trading

Equities.com launches unlimited trading via Tradier Brokerage, Transforming into a news & fintech portal

Featured Topics

more Commodities>>

Commodities

Energy demand steps back in play
Advertisement
more Volatility>>

Volatility

Volatility & opportunity in the energy sector
more Financials>>

Financials

Daily Price Action: E-mini S&P 500
more Options>>

Options

Trading Vertical Option Spreads

Irony futures

By Philip McBride Johnson

June 11, 2013 • Reprints

Throughout the Dodd-Frank Act's creation in Congress, swap users and dealers insisted that swaps are sufficiently distinguishable from futures and options that they should be addressed separately, so they were. For example, swap dealers needed a new registration category, as did swap markets.

Recall that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) allowed swaps, with conditions, for a long time but as a "policy" or "exemption." It has never said that they are not within the family of futures contracts or options that the Commodity Exchange Act has covered since the 1920s. Indeed, if they weren't, the CFTC would have no reason to act at all.

Aside from having been entered into privately, there is precious little about the workings of an interest rate or energy swap that is different from an interest rate or energy futures contract. A credit default swap is structured like a credit default option. But Congress felled forests to construct a massive law on the assumption that folding swaps into the CFTC's existing futures and options regime (with exemption powers intact) simply would not do.

Now, however, the song has been rewritten. The CFTC is being sued by Bloomberg, among others, for setting collateral requirements for some swaps higher than initial margins on competing futures contracts. The case was thrown out in the lower court but may be appealed.

And the wiley futures exchanges have launched futures contracts on some swaps with this advantage in mind. They will be traded and cleared like any other futures contract. If there was really any difference between those products for most swap users, these initiatives would crash and burn but so far, so good.

And so, after pleading for separate treatment in Congress, we now learn that swaps aren't all that different after all. "Be careful what you wish for" has never been more apt.

About the Author

Copyright 2014 Bloomberg. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Related Articles
Fed tightens a quarter in Yellen's last meeting
CFTC obtains consent order against California firm for fraud
MF Global is gone, but Corzine may return
CFTC commissioner floats user fee
Learning the lessons of platinum partners
Previous
CBOE hit with $6 million fine by SEC for regulatory failures
Next
Safety net scaled back as Senate passes agriculture bill
Related Terms
Bloomberg 5254Congress 1894Commodity Futures Trading Commission 1289cftc 937Regulations 267Dodd-Frank 182Swaps 125energy futures 54futurization 2massive law 2energy swap 1

Free Newsletter Modern Trader Follow

Main menu

  • Futures
    • Modern Trader Magazine
    • Commodities
    • Futures Mag Archives
    • ETFs
    • Financials
    • Forex
    • Managed Funds
    • Market Analysis
    • News
    • Options
    • Regulation
    • Technology
    • Trading Strategies
    • Education
    • Futures Op-Ed
  • Favorites
    • Alpha Pages Most Popular
    • Futures Magazine
    • Modern Trader Magazine
    • Most Popular
    • Slideshows & Lists
    • Special Topics
      • Alpha Hunters
      • Bad Boys
      • FINtech
      • High-Frequency Trading
      • Trader's Life
      • Trading Strategies
      • FUTURES MAG's 500th ISSUE
      • We asked traders
  • Traders
    • Market Data
    • Hot Charts
    • Interactive Charts
    • Trading Calendar
  • FINalternatives
  • Hard Assets
    • Home
    • Base Metals
    • Precious Metals
    • Rare Earth Metals
    • Commodities
    • Mining Investments
    • Slideshows
  • Modern Trader
    • Subscribe
    • Past Issues
  • All +
    • Follow Us +
      • FuturesMag
      • Newsletters
      • Facebook
      • Google+
      • Linkedin
      • Twitter
      • RSS Feeds
    • About Us +
      • About
      • Advertise
      • Contact
      • Contribute
      • Privacy Policy
  • !
images