Traders of Japanese government bonds want the central bank to buy more short-term notes and to conduct purchases more frequently, according to Bank of Japan officials after a meeting with market participants.
The attendees said the BOJ should increase buying of one- to-five year notes and suggested smaller purchases at each operation, a BOJ official told reporters yesterday in Tokyo, asking not to be named, citing the central bank’s policy. The average duration of bond purchases now is about seven years, the official said.
The BOJ is trying to steady a debt market where volatility has risen to the highest in four years in the wake of unprecedented monetary easing steps last month. Yesterday’s gathering with bond market participants is the third under the tenure of Governor Haruhiko Kuroda, who last week reiterated a pledge to improve communication on central bank policy.
“The bank has allowed excessive volatility to remain in the JGB market for as much as seven weeks,” Shogo Fujita, the chief Japanese bond strategist in Tokyo at Bank of America Merrill Lynch, one of the 24 primary dealers obliged to bid at government auctions, said before yesterday’s meeting. “The situation doesn’t raise Kuroda’s credibility so far.”
The yield on the benchmark 10-year Japanese government bond jumped to a more than one-year high of 1% last week, even after the BOJ pledged to double bond purchases to end 15 years of deflation in the world’s third-largest economy. Kuroda indicated this week that Japan can weather an increase in yields if it occurs alongside an economic recovery.
Japan’s Topix Index of shares has surged about 60% since the middle of November amid optimism for expanded fiscal and monetary stimulus under Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and Kuroda at the central bank. Even so, rising JGB yields threaten the sustainability of what’s already the world’s largest debt burden and undermine the government’s aim to stoke growth through low borrowing costs.
The five-year JGB yield closed at 0.41% yesterday and earlier this month reached a two-year high of 0.455%. That’s almost five times the record low of 0.095% reached in March ahead of Kuroda’s appointment as governor.
Participants at yesterday’s meeting said increased buying of one-to-five year notes by the BOJ was desirable to reduce volatility, according to the central bank official. The BOJ will release its bond-operation plan for June today, the official said.
Most attendees agreed to a proposal to boost bond-purchase operations to 10 or more per month from 8 times currently, the official said. They didn’t think the BOJ should set a rigid target for bond buying or give notice for each operation as the Federal Reserve does, the official told reporters.
Implied volatility of Japan’s 10-year note futures, a measure of expected moves used to price options, climbed to 7.23% on May 28, the highest since November 2008, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. A sale of 20-year debt this week drew the lowest demand since August 2012.
The 10-year JGB yield rose three basis points to 0.935% yesterday, the highest close since April 2012. The rate has almost tripled from the record low 0.315% reached on April 5.
After meetings with market representatives last month, the BOJ revised its monthly bond purchases to “approximately 7+ trillion yen” ($69 billion) per month from an earlier estimate of 7.5 trillion yen.
BOJ policy board member Ryuzo Miyao said this week that the central bank’s bond buying will “strongly support” growth by keeping interest rates lower even when improved economic prospects put upward pressure on borrowing costs.
So far, policy makers are getting the opposite results. As JGB yields climbed, the benchmark lending rate for large corporations, known as the prime rate, rose 10 basis points from its record low to 1.25% on May 10, according to Mizuho Corporate Bank Ltd. Rates for 35-year home loans inched higher to 1.81% this month from an all-time low of 1.8% in April, data from the Japan Housing Finance Agency show.
For supporters of Abenomics like Jesper Koll, JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s head of equity research in Tokyo, the rise in JGB yields is a “healthy sign” that the economy is improving and investors are seeking riskier assets. For J. Kyle Bass, whose Hayman Advisors LP made $500 million amid the U.S. subprime crisis and is now betting on a fiscal collapse in Japan, it means the BOJ will have to “dramatically” increase bond-buying efforts to counteract investor selling.
“The BOJ dominates asset markets for better or worse,” Bill Gross, who runs the world’s biggest bond fund at Pacific Investment Management Co., said in a post on Twitter. “Watch JGBs, the yen and the exodus from each.”
Japan’s outstanding debt was 991.6 trillion yen at the end of March, a ministry report showed this month. It’s projected to reach 245% of gross domestic product this year, according to an International Monetary Fund estimate, the highest ratio in the world.
Minutes released this week of the BOJ’s April 26 meeting showed divisions on the policy board, where “a few” members see difficulties meeting a 2% price goal by the end of March 2016. One member said the bond market could become unstable again, while others said that swings in financial markets had been triggered by perceptions that the BOJ had conflicting goals -- trying to push down interest rates while pursuing inflation.
There are no signs investors have “excessively bullish expectations,” Kuroda said in Tokyo on May 26. He cited an April BOJ report indicating rates could rise by between one and three percentage points in an improving economy without causing financial instability.
Kuroda’s BOJ has shown it will step into bond markets to stem volatility. When JGB yields touched 1% on May 23 and a plunge in bond futures set off a circuit breaker on the stock exchange, the central bank supplied 2 trillion yen to the financial system, its second such market-calming infusion this month.