Jump to navigation

Free Newsletter Modern Trader Follow

Main menu

  • Futures
    • Modern Trader Magazine
    • Commodities
    • Futures Mag Archives
    • ETFs
    • Financials
    • Forex
    • Managed Funds
    • Market Analysis
    • News
    • Options
    • Regulation
    • Technology
    • Trading Strategies
    • Education
    • Futures Op-Ed
  • Favorites
    • Alpha Pages Most Popular
    • Futures Magazine
    • Modern Trader Magazine
    • Most Popular
    • Slideshows & Lists
    • Special Topics
      • Alpha Hunters
      • Bad Boys
      • FINtech
      • High-Frequency Trading
      • Trader's Life
      • Trading Strategies
      • FUTURES MAG's 500th ISSUE
      • We asked traders
  • Traders
    • Market Data
    • Hot Charts
    • Interactive Charts
    • Trading Calendar
  • FINalternatives
  • Hard Assets
    • Home
    • Base Metals
    • Precious Metals
    • Rare Earth Metals
    • Commodities
    • Mining Investments
    • Slideshows
  • Modern Trader
    • Subscribe
    • Past Issues
  • All +
    • Follow Us +
      • FuturesMag
      • Newsletters
      • Facebook
      • Google+
      • Linkedin
      • Twitter
      • RSS Feeds
    • About Us +
      • About
      • Advertise
      • Contact
      • Contribute
      • Privacy Policy
  • !
Follow Futures          
       
more >>

We Asked Traders

We asked traders for their opinion on the launch of bitcoin futures

Sponsored Content

Trading

Equities.com launches unlimited trading via Tradier Brokerage, Transforming into a news & fintech portal

Featured Topics

more Commodities>>

Commodities

Energy demand steps back in play
Advertisement
more Volatility>>

Volatility

Volatility & opportunity in the energy sector
more Financials>>

Financials

Daily Price Action: E-mini S&P 500
more Options>>

Options

Trading Vertical Option Spreads

Financial regulators: Policemen or tax collectors?

Ka-ching

By Philip McBride Johnson

November 29, 2012 • Reprints

 

The press reports almost daily about commercial and financial firms that have sustained massive losses from trading (UBS, JP Morgan etc.), negligence (BP) or alleged chicanery (Barclays). Soon thereafter, we learn that the Government has exacted huge fines from these companies as well. In at least one case (BP), a multi-billion dollar penalty is expected even after the firm spent tens of billions of dollars repairing its mess. It seems that blood in the water does indeed attract sharks.

They call it a "civil monetary penalty" or a "fine," but those terms seem hollow when a financial firm itself is whacked for millions of dollars by regulators after suffering huge losses from bad bets or cowboy traders. "Piling on" seems a better description. 

True, the firms made mistakes, perhaps for all the wrong reasons (e.g., when has a successful bettor been called a "rogue trader"?). And, sure, supervision and standards usually need improvement. But adding another layer of losses in the name of "enforcement" is an odd way to express disapproval.

Who does this hurt? Management does not pay. The burden for both the original losses and the subsequent fines falls upon the shareholders whose investment declines and upon the consumers who suffer higher fees for the firms' services - both innocent bystanders.

Let's face it. Regulators in these circumstances are acting like tax collectors. They brag about being Government profit centers, assessing some multiple of their budgets in fines each year, with the excess going into the U.S. Treasury just like our official tax payments.

Tax reform is on everyone's lips these days. As long as the Treasury can benefit from the misery of financial firms, while responsible management is left untouched, this is an area where genuine "tax reform" is sorely needed.

 

About the Author

Related Articles
Fed tightens a quarter in Yellen's last meeting
CFTC obtains consent order against California firm for fraud
MF Global is gone, but Corzine may return
CFTC commissioner floats user fee
Learning the lessons of platinum partners
Previous
Treasuries erase losses as Boehner says no deficit plan progress
Next
Hong Kong bourse wins approval for $2.2 billion LME takeover
Related Terms
U.S. Treasury 854UBS 607Barclays 399JP Morgan 381Regulation 344BP 342JPMorgan 176Barclays 103UBS 77BP 46cicil fines 1

Free Newsletter Modern Trader Follow

Main menu

  • Futures
    • Modern Trader Magazine
    • Commodities
    • Futures Mag Archives
    • ETFs
    • Financials
    • Forex
    • Managed Funds
    • Market Analysis
    • News
    • Options
    • Regulation
    • Technology
    • Trading Strategies
    • Education
    • Futures Op-Ed
  • Favorites
    • Alpha Pages Most Popular
    • Futures Magazine
    • Modern Trader Magazine
    • Most Popular
    • Slideshows & Lists
    • Special Topics
      • Alpha Hunters
      • Bad Boys
      • FINtech
      • High-Frequency Trading
      • Trader's Life
      • Trading Strategies
      • FUTURES MAG's 500th ISSUE
      • We asked traders
  • Traders
    • Market Data
    • Hot Charts
    • Interactive Charts
    • Trading Calendar
  • FINalternatives
  • Hard Assets
    • Home
    • Base Metals
    • Precious Metals
    • Rare Earth Metals
    • Commodities
    • Mining Investments
    • Slideshows
  • Modern Trader
    • Subscribe
    • Past Issues
  • All +
    • Follow Us +
      • FuturesMag
      • Newsletters
      • Facebook
      • Google+
      • Linkedin
      • Twitter
      • RSS Feeds
    • About Us +
      • About
      • Advertise
      • Contact
      • Contribute
      • Privacy Policy
  • !
images