Nasdaq makes new high, but S&P 500 cannot

Market Snapshot for session ending 2-13-12:

 

Last

Day Change

%Change

S&P 500 Index

1351.77

+9.13

+.68%

Dow Jones Industrials

12874.00

+72.80

+.57%

NASDAQ Composite

2931.39

+27.51

+.95%

Value Line Arithmetic Index

3012.80

+28.44

+.95%

Minor Cycle
(Short-term trend lasting days to a few weeks)
Positive / Neutral

Intermediate Cycle
(Medium trend lasting weeks to several months)
Positive

Major Cycle
(Long-term trend lasting several months to years)
Positive / Neutral

Market Overview – What We Know:

  • NASDAQ Composite makes new short to intermediate-term high Monday, but S&P 500, Dow 30, and Value Line Index do not, despite broad market strength.
  • Trading volume shrank by about 4% in the S&P 500 Monday.
  • Short and Intermediate-term trends remain “Overbought.”
  • Weakness below lower edge of 10-Day Price Channel (1322.50—Tuesday) would suggest beginning of end of Minor Cycle advance.
  • Short-term Momentum in S&P 500 remains marginally positive, but it wouldn’t take much to turn indicator negative to reverse currently positive Minor Cycle trend.
  • Daily MAAD was positive by 16 to 2 Monday, but strength was not good enough to cause indicator to better its February 8 plot high. Weekly MAAD continues to underperform.
  • Cumulative Volume (CV) in S&P 500 remains above late October resistance highs, but Emini CV remains weak. Both remain substantially weaker than prices relative to May 2011 highs.
  • Daily CPFL was positive Monday by 3.33 to 1. CPFL has yet to better its late October resistance high and has confirmed little of strength since October lows.
Index Daily / Weekly / Monthly Stops Weekly Monthly
2/13 2/14 2/15 2/16 2/17 2/17 2/29

S&P 500
Index

SELL
1318.59

SELL
1322.50

SELL
1326.97

SELL
1331.30

SELL
1333.74

SELL
1230.02

SELL
1218.82

Dow Jones
Industrials

SELL
12664.54

SELL
12690.04

SELL
12718.84

SELL
12748.55

SELL
12756.81

SELL
11938.90

SELL
11481.71

NASDAQ
Composite

SELL
2837.09

SELL
2849.37

SELL
2860.86

SELL
2872.61

SELL
2880.65

SELL
2578.28

SELL
2592.57

Value Line
Index

SELL
2925.40

SELL
2941.29

SELL
2956.08

SELL
2968.44

SELL
2974.61

SELL
2630.47

SELL
2708.65

Market Overview – What We Think:

  • Lateral action of S&P 500 over past several sessions could lead to creation of Minor Cycle high. Lacking a new high in the index, we wonder how much longer short-term trend that has been positive since mid-December will be able to last.
  • Ongoing upside failure of majority of our key indicators is strong indication rally since October lows could prove not to be resumption of the primary bull trend begun in October 2009. More likely scenario could be powerful countertrend rally that might “hook” many investors because of recent flirtations with May 2011 highs.
  • We must continue to suggest market’s true internal “health” is measured and reflected by condition and outlook of our key indicators. Higher prices can occur, but without indicator confirmation, strength is definitely suspect.
  • Ongoing struggle relative to 2011 highs gives us feeling there is certain inevitability about this market that may ultimately not accrue to benefit of bullish crowd.

Click charts to enlarge

Next page: Indicator review

We are also updating the daily chart of both the Call/Put Dollar Value Flow Line (CPFL) and Most Actives Advance/Decline Line (MAAD) indicators every day and providing the most recent raw data so you can begin to plot the indicators on your own (see below). The weekly equity index indicator summary provides longer-term commentary based on these indicators.

The definitions of the indicators along with links to the original stories provide helpful background. Also, Robert describes these indicators in a recent I-Trade show presentation available online.

Click charts to enlarge

MAAD Daily data for past 30 days*            CPFL data for past 30 Days

Date

NYSE Adv

NYSE Dec

Date

OEX Call $Volume

OEX Put $Volume

12-30-11

6

13

12-30-11

6124

10362

1-3-12

19

1

1-3-12

35670

29266

1-4-12

13

7

1-4-12

26802

22155

1-5-12

16

4

1-5-12

61415

21835

1-6-12

7

13

1-6-12

22284

25868

1-9-12

17

3

1-9-12

9556

14616

1-10-12

14

4

1-10-12

49137

22774

1-11-12

15

5

1-11-12

33050

16064

1-12-12

15

5

1-12-12

38719

17173

1-13-12

3

15

1-13-12

52855

26824

1-17-12

10

9

1-17-12

55193

29267

1-18-12

18

1

1-18-12

51107

17292

1-19-12

17

3

1-19-12

122407

21066

1-20-12

12

7

1-20-12

28217

22777

1-23-12

13

6

1-23-12

21447

40321

1-24-12

9

11

1-24-12

23867

17961

1-25-12

14

2

1-25-12

48455

32170

1-26-12

4

15

1-26-12

35614

34927

1-27-12

7

13

1-27-12

35352

26624

1-30-12

8

11

1-30-12

31907

21965

1-31-12

10

10

1-31-12

22035

19605

2-1-12

19

1

2-1-12

59444

33008

2-2-12

11

7

2-2-12

26098

13336

2-3-12

19

1

2-3-12

75145

15813

2-6-12

8

12

2-6-12

48497

15474

2-7-12

10

9

2-7-12

51427

27147

2-8-12

15

5

2-8-12

40749

15883

2-9-12

8

11

2-9-12

25312

17956

2-10-12

3

17

2-10-12

38202

39263

2-13-12

16

2

2-13-12

45728

13705

*Note: Unchanged issues are not counted.

Robert McCurtain is a technical analyst/market timer, private investor and financial markets consultant based in New York City. He is a member of the Market Technicians Association and can be reached at traderbob@nyc.rr.com.

If you would like to read more about how the CPFL is constructed, read a Futures article on the concept. This link will take you to the MAAD article.

Page 1 of 2
Comments
comments powered by Disqus

eNewsletter Signup

Get the latest news and timely trading strategies for stock, options, forex, commodity, and financial derivatives markets with Futures' Daily Market Focus - FREE!