Stock market minor cycle dicey

Some years ago in high school sophomore math we were being instructed in how to compute an algebraic equation. Very carefully the teacher went through each procedural step as she worked toward the final result. Finally, the multi-stepped problem was complete. But alas, the work of the class had only begun since a pop quiz was presented to a collective groan. To give confidence to some students, such as your intrepid writer, the instructor said, "Don’t worry. Simply complete the algorithm like I did with the example on the blackboard."

That’s just what most of us did. We sought to work out the problem just as the teacher had done. Unfortunately, when the test papers were distributed many of the answers were wrong, including ours, even thought the solution to the second equation looked as if it ought to follow the same route to completion as the first.

The market has often proven to be a bit like that old algebraic problem in high school math. It looks like it ought to play out the same way, but sometimes it doesn’t. In fact, the pullback that developed last week and which followed the February 18 index highs looks at this point a lot like the little bear trap that culminated in the January 31 interim low that was then followed by strength to new highs for the move.

So what does the down move last week have in common with the weakness a month ago? First, index prices settled back onto a defined Intermediate-term uptrend line that stretches back to the late August "pullback" lows that were a test of the absolute Intermediate-term lows put in place in early July. That trendline gained definition with the December lows and held through the late January pullback.

Second, one of our key indicators, the Call/Put $Value Flow Line (CPFL) gave no ground on the downside last week and rallied to new highs using both Daily and Weekly data on Friday. Clearly, options players remain positive on the market and apparently think that pullbacks should be used to accumulate shares.

And third, albeit at "Overbought" levels, the larger Intermediate Cycle that has remained positive for several months continues to remain positive. Put another way, until proven otherwise, short-term selling could be viewed as mere weakness within the context of that larger trend.

But there are negatives, some new, some old. First, unlike during the January drawdown, Short-term Momentum turned negative this time for the first time since the month-long correction that began early last November and which lead to the December lows.

Second, one of our two key Trading Oscillators turned negative last Thursday after remaining positive since December 2. The other Oscillator remains positive, but not by much.

Third, Cumulative Volume on the Daily Cycle has stubbornly refused to better its late April plot highs (See chart Below) as that indicator has continued to suggest that despite new highs in the market for the move that began in March 2009, the rally from the July lows has been spurred by weaker players. Such underpinnings do not make for a warm and fuzzy feeling on the Major Cycle.

Click chart to enlarge



Fourth, 10 Day Price Channels, the first "failsafe" levels in our Timing Model after the realization of initial upside Profit Targets were met, were fractured last week in all of the major indexes. The Price Channel relationship to index prices has now flipped back to the Buy side in the event confirmatory action of a short-term negative is not forthcoming and more strength develops.

Coming in on the side of Neutrality, however, our Most Actives Advance/Decline Line (MAAD) hit a high back on February 17 using Daily data and on February 18 using Weekly data. No downside supports were broken on either cycle to suggest that the market is currently "sorta maybe" until further price definition unfolds.

So, given the evidence, we are left with three possible scenarios:

First, the near-term trendline supports hold, the market stabilizes further after a bit of bottom testing above last Thursday’s lows, and then resumes its upward trek while working toward those projected Intermediate Cycle and measured move highs we suggested as possibilities last week (1360-1389—S&P 500, 12444-12766—Dow 30, 2953-2991—NASDAQ, and 3107-3150—Value Line).

Or second, the short-term weakens further, the uptrend line stretching back toward those August retest lows is terminated, and the Intermediate-term Cycle in effect since early July is challenged. In this case we would look for a possible test of Intermediate-term statistical supports toward defined 10-week Price Channels (see Table Below), but not a termination of the Intermediate-term advance itself.

Or third, more concerted selling develops and not only is the Intermediate Cycle challenged, but the uptrend that began last July is ended, albeit within the context of a still positive Major Cycle advance that would allow price weakness to the lower edge of defined 10-Month Price Channels (See Table below).

Index

Daily Stops

Weekly Monthly
2/28 3/1 3/2 3/3 3/4 3/4 2/28

S&P

Last
1319.88

BUY
1334.86

BUY
1336.25

BUY
1333.54

BUY
1329.67

BUY
1327.82

SELL
1276.64

SELL
1054.96

Dow 30

Last
12130.45

BUY
12303.06

BUY
12323.45

BUY
12309.50

BUY
12279.24

BUY
12255.14

SELL
11744.97

SELL
9977.84

NASDAQ

Last
2781.05

BUY
2821.17

BUY
2820.27

BUY
2810.71

BUY
2798.80

BUY
2794.39

SELL
2713.76

SELL
2145.96

Val. Line

Last
3005.51

BUY
3039.85

BUY
3043.33

BUY
3036.19

BUY
3024.12

BUY
3020.28

SELL
2908.12

SELL
2241.20



Note: Stop levels, a function of the extant trend, are based on the trailing moving average price channels for the Highs or the Lows of an index. Whether or not a specific index is suggesting a "Buy" or Sell" is determined by whether or not index prices are above or below the current channel Stop levels. Stop levels should only be used as an entry or exit guide and in conjunction with other market entry and exit strategies.

McCurtain Most Actives Advance/Decline Line (MAAD)
Last week Daily and Weekly MAAD data were unable to better their February 17 and 18 highs and the best levels since March 2009. But given the limited nature of selling, so far, in the broad market over the past several days and the somewhat anemic reaction of this indicator to weakness and the fact the Daily MAAD Ratio has already dipped into "oversold" territory, it’s possible that selling could prove to be relatively short lived even if bids progress somewhat below last Thursday’s lows.

We must continue to point out, however, and this has been one of our pet themes for months, that MAAD relative to broad market action has not done as well since March 2009 as in previous market up moves. While there may be many reasons as to why the so-called "Smart Money" has been less enthusiastic that previously, the fact is that it has. Put another way, it would take far less market weakness to push MAAD down to new lows than it would index prices unless there was catastrophic selling, an eventuality that does not seem likely at this time.

Click charts to enlarge

McCurtain Call/Put Dollar Value Flow Line (CPFL)
Despite selling in the major indexes last week, CPFL rallied to new highs for the move on both the Daily and Weekly Cycles to suggest that options players remain optimistic. While this divergence from price action does not preclude more weakness in the broad market, it does suggest that the lack of a defined upside disparity could accrue to the benefit of the bulls on the short-term in that any weakness which develops could be of short-term term duration and could prove to be a buying opportunity.

If, however, CPFL begins to weaken in conjunction with market prices and then fails to stage a rebound once an interim price low is made, at that point we would begin to worry that the larger cycles could be in jeopardy since option players have had a tendency to "fade" larger cycle highs in preparation for more sustained declines.

Click charts to enlarge

Conclusion
While last week’s downdraft which resulted in losses of 1.7% in the S&P 500, 2.1% in the Dow 30, 1.8% in the NASDAQ, and 1.9% in the Value Line Index could be the beginning of a larger cycle decline, we doubt it. If that prognosis proves to be overly optimistic and prices decline below defined Intermediate-term uptrends that stretch back to the late August re-test lows, we would then look toward Intermediate-term Price Channel supports while assuming that near-term weakness would not terminate the Intermediate-term uptrend.

Following such a smaller cycle pullback, however, prices would have to rally to new highs with indicator confirmation. If prices rallied, but did not make new highs and there was notable deterioration on the indicator front, we would then have to seriously consider that the eight-month-old rally is over, but probably within the context of a still positive Major Cycle trend.

MAAD data for past 30 Weeks* CPFL data for past 30 Weeks

Date

NYSE Adv

NYSE Dec

Date

OEX Call $Volume

OEX Put $Volume

7-9-10

18

2

7-9-10

635690

110808

7-16-10

9

11

7-16-10

171633

445073

7-23-10

16

4

7-23-10

322870

174663

7-30-10

15

5

7-30-10

199970

217368

8-6-10

15

5

8-6-10

271701

115037

8-13-10

3

16

8-13-10

132060

409972

8-20-10

8

12

8-20-10

176830

488032

8-27-10

6

14

8-27-10

207995

222943

9-3-10

17

3

9-3-10

488323

102016

9-10-10

12

7

9-10-10

287697

82863

9-17-10

15

5

9-17-10

289703

112410

9-24-10

12

8

9-24-10

209124

100570

10-1-10

9

11

10-1-10

145020

121894

10-8-10

14

6

10-8-10

394156

98483

10-15-10

10

10

10-15-10

476975

115923

10-22-10

11

9

10-22-10

2575024

116468

10-29-10

10

10

10-29-10

376133

120924

11-5-10

13

7

11-5-10

547056

71345

11-12-10

5

15

11-12-10

203906

305387

11-19-10

7

13

11-19-10

241420

143672

11-26-10

5

15

11-26-10

116916

149196

12-3-10

16

4

12-3-10

701973

55878

12-10-10

15

5

12-10-10

395991

42814

12-17-10

9

11

12-17-10

441634

61008

12-24-10

17

3

12-24-10

177600

88159

12-31-10

16

4

12-31-10

154527

60647

1-7-11

16

4

1-7-11

458733

97512

1-14-11

12

7

1-14-11

327777

49317

1-21-11

5

15

1-21-11

376104

106618

1-28-11

6

14

1-28-11

227154

249821

2-4-11

17

3

2-4-11

590448

67646

2-11-11

13

7

2-11-11

514220

98361

2-18-11

12

8

2-18-11

2557718

102605

2-25-11

5

15

2-25-11

893080

195746



*Note: All data is for week ending on Friday even though ending date may be a holiday.
Unchanged issues in MAAD calculations are not counted.

MAAD data for past 30 days** CPFL data for past 30 Days

Date

NYSE Adv

NYSE Dec

Date

OEX Call $Volume

OEX Put $Volume

1-13-11

6

14

1-13-11

54780

20758

1-14-11

15

5

1-14-11

39593

23222

1-17-10

Holiday

1-17-10

Holiday

1-18-11

7

12

1-18-11

98369

20105

1-19-11

5

14

1-19-11

35520

52589

1-20-11

10

10

1-20-11

48321

58809

1-21-11

15

5

1-21-11

239601

26839

1-24-11

12

8

1-24-11

71963

30755

1-25-11

6

13

1-25-11

64933

30082

1-26-11

8

12

1-26-11

96297

29774

1-27-11

13

7

1-27-11

39290

24578

1-28-11

6

14

1-28-11

49833

103507

1-31-11

14

6

1-31-11

241142

34874

2-1-11

14

6

2-1-11

120947

37779

2-2-11

8

12

2-2-11

133037

16643

2-3-11

9

9

2-3-11

28978

24133

2-4-11

9

11

2-4-11

121512

15259

2-7-11

14

5

2-7-11

92432

24561

2-8-11

13

7

2-8-11

94867

28120

2-9-11

10

10

2-9-11

147855

29984

2-10-11

6

14

2-10-11

133883

37629

2-11-11

12

7

2-11-11

63818

24031

2-14-11

12

8

2-14-11

34610

20791

2-15-11

5

13

2-15-11

2061666

22531

2-16-11

13

7

2-16-11

68997

38095

2-17-11

12

7

2-17-11

282423

21138

2-18-11

7

13

2-18-11

85240

56972

2-22-11

6

14

2-22-11

752594

117396

2-23-11

9

11

2-23-11

100127

60064

2-24-11

7

13

2-24-11

34581

94353

2-25-11

16

4

2-25-11

35547

26744

**Note: Unchanged issues are not counted.

Robert McCurtain is a technical analyst, market timer and private investor based in New York City. If you would like to read more about how the CPFL is constructed, read a Futures article on the concept. This will take you to the MAAD article. Robert can be reached at traderbob@nyc.rr.com.

Page 1 of 3
Comments
comments powered by Disqus

eNewsletter Signup

Get the latest news and timely trading strategies for stock, options, forex, commodity, and financial derivatives markets with Futures' Daily Market Focus - FREE!